Tax Relief: What a Difference an Election Makes!
by Gregg Hull
While I support any and all tax relief that leaves more money in the pockets of New Mexico taxpayers, the political double standard surrounding the latest income tax proposal is hard to ignore.
During my campaign for Governor, I introduced my Four Steps to Zero plan to responsibly phase out New Mexico’s personal income tax, beginning with relief on the first portion of taxable income. Representative Derrick Lente warned my proposal “would have a disastrous impact on New Mexico,” while Deb Haaland criticized it as a tax break for the wealthy.
Now, just weeks after the election, Representative Lente (NM House Tax Chair) is proposing his own income tax relief plan, including an immediate reduction in the top marginal tax rate from 5.9% to 4.7%. That’s a reduction of more than 20% in the top rate, benefiting the very high-income taxpayers they criticized my plan for helping.
And what about the media?
When I introduced my plan, news coverage prominently featured warnings of financial disaster and accusations that it favored wealthy taxpayers. Now, when a Democrat proposes substantial income tax relief, including an immediate reduction in the highest tax rate, the headlines emphasize affordability and helping New Mexico families.
So which is it?
Is reducing income taxes a dangerous giveaway to the wealthy, or is it meaningful financial relief for hardworking New Mexico families? Does the answer depend on the merits of the policy, or the political party of the person proposing it?
Even Senate Majority Leader Peter Wirth now suggests these tax reforms deserve consideration, while acknowledging that lawmakers have previously been “constrained.”
Constrained by what?
After eight years of extraordinary state revenue growth, billions in oil and gas revenue, and annual revenue projections approaching $15 billion, what exactly prevented our Legislature from delivering meaningful, lasting tax relief before now?
And here’s another interesting coincidence. Voters just approved salaries for state legislators beginning in 2029, currently estimated at approximately $68,000 annually. Legislators may also continue earning income from private employment or businesses. Depending on their combined incomes, some lawmakers could personally benefit from the very top-rate reduction now being proposed.
Shouldn’t taxpayers know how this proposal might affect the legislators voting on it?
I welcome Representative Lente’s proposal and any bipartisan effort to allow New Mexicans to keep more of their hard-earned money. But taxpayers deserve consistency from elected officials and equal scrutiny from the media.
New Mexicans also deserve an explanation for why meaningful income tax relief was portrayed as financially irresponsible before the election but is now receiving a warmer reception.
Tax relief didn’t suddenly become good policy on November 4th.
It was good policy when I proposed it, and it remains good policy today.
New Mexicans deserved it then, and they deserve it now.
Gregg Hull
Former Mayor of Rio Rancho
2026 Republican Nominee for Governor of New Mexico
